Where the saving comes from
Renting at the airport adds a concession fee, a percentage the airport charges the rental company and passes to you. A neighborhood branch does not. Across several days that difference is not small, though it narrows once you add the ride into town.
Parking is the real cost downtown
Here is the line item that surprises people. Metered street parking is capped, usually at a couple of hours, so it is no good for a car you are keeping for days. Garages are the workable option, and the daily rate differs sharply between cities. Ask your hotel what parking costs: many bill it nightly, on top of the room.
The catch on opening times
City-center locations run on business hours, not the extended schedule of an airport counter. A good number shut at midday Saturday and do not open Sunday at all. If either end of your rental lands on a weekend, confirm the hours rather than assume them.
Driving in and out of the center
Build in time for rush hour: leaving a city center at 5pm is not the same as leaving at 10am. On the return, refuel before you reach the center, since central gas stations are few and charge for it.
Frequently asked questions
Downtown usually starts lower because there is no airport concession fee. But add parking and the ride into town, the gap narrows and sometimes reverses. It depends on how long you keep the car.
A garage is the realistic option for anything beyond a couple of hours, because meters cap how long you can stay. Daily garage rates differ widely from one city to another. Where the hotel has its own parking, compare its nightly charge against a nearby garage rather than assuming it is included.
Expect office hours, unlike airport counters that stay open late. Many close at midday on Saturday and Sunday is frequently closed. Plan the pickup and the return around that, especially if your flight lands late.
Usually yes, and inside the same city there is frequently no charge. Ask when you book, since it pairs the lower downtown rate with a drop-off that fits your flight. Confirm it on the booking, not at the counter.