Where the saving comes from
Airport branches carry a concession recovery fee, a percentage the airport charges the rental company and passes to you. A neighborhood branch does not. Across several days that difference is not small, though the rideshare to get there eats into it.
What downtown actually costs you
This is what people underestimate. Street parking is metered and time-limited, which does not work for a car you keep overnight. A garage is the practical answer, with daily rates that vary widely from one city to the next. Ask your hotel what parking costs: a nightly parking charge on top of the room rate is standard.
Shorter hours than the airport
Downtown branches keep office hours, not the long airport schedule. A good number shut at midday Saturday and do not open Sunday at all. If your pickup or return falls on a weekend, check the hours before you book.
Getting out and back in
Build in time for rush hour: the drive out at five in the afternoon is a different trip than the same drive mid-morning. On the return, fill the tank on the way in, because downtown gas stations are scarce and priced accordingly.
Frequently asked questions
Downtown usually starts lower since the airport concession fee does not apply. Once you add parking and the trip in from the airport, the two can end up level or the other way around. The longer the rental, the more parking decides it.
Parking garages are the practical answer for anything beyond a couple of hours, because meters cap how long you can stay. Daily garage rates differ widely from one city to another. If your hotel offers parking, compare its nightly charge against a nearby garage rather than assuming it is included.
They run on business hours, which is the main difference with an airport counter. Many close at midday on Saturday and a lot of them do not open Sunday. Work both ends of your rental around those hours, especially if your flight lands late.
Most companies allow it, and within the same city it is often free. It is worth asking, because it combines the cheaper downtown rate with a convenient return. Get it on the reservation rather than sorting it out on the day.